The "renting is throwing money away" argument is one of the most persistent myths in personal finance. The reality is more complicated — sometimes renting is the smarter financial move, and sometimes buying wins by a mile. It depends on your local market, your financial situation, and how long you plan to stay.
The True Cost of Buying (Not Just the Mortgage)
Most people compare rent to a mortgage payment and call it a day. But homeownership includes a lot of costs that renters never pay:
Monthly Homeownership Costs on a $350,000 Home
Mortgage payment (P&I): ~$1,850/month (6.5% rate, 20% down)
Property taxes: ~$350/month (varies wildly by state)
Homeowners insurance: ~$150/month
Maintenance (1% rule): ~$290/month
PMI (if < 20% down): $0-$200/month
HOA (if applicable): $0-$400/month
True monthly cost: $2,640 - $3,240+
Compare that to the mortgage payment alone ($1,850) and you can see why many new homeowners feel blindsided. The "hidden" costs add 40-75% on top of the mortgage payment.
The True Cost of Renting
Renting has its own costs, but they're simpler:
Rent payment: Your monthly cost. This is fixed for your lease term.
Renter's insurance: $15-$30/month. Cheap and worth it.
Opportunity cost: If you'd need $70,000 for a down payment and closing costs, that money could be invested instead. At a 7% average return, $70,000 grows to about $137,000 in 10 years.
That's it. No maintenance, no property taxes, no surprise roof repairs. When the fridge breaks, you call the landlord.
The 5-Year Rule
The biggest factor in the rent vs buy equation is how long you plan to stay.
💡 The General Rule
Staying less than 3 years: Almost always better to rent. Buying costs (closing costs, agent fees) eat into any equity you build.
Staying 3-5 years: Depends on your local market. Run the numbers.
Staying 5+ years: Buying usually wins financially, assuming a stable or growing market.
The reason: buying a home costs 2-5% in closing costs upfront, and selling costs 5-6% in agent commissions and fees. On a $350,000 home, that's $25,000-$38,000 in transaction costs. You need to build enough equity to offset those costs before buying makes financial sense.
When Renting Wins
You might relocate within 3-5 years. Job changes, relationship changes, or just wanting to explore — if there's a reasonable chance you'll move, renting gives you flexibility without financial penalty.
Your local market is overpriced. In some cities, the price-to-rent ratio is so high that renting and investing the difference clearly wins. If a comparable home costs $500,000 to buy but $2,000/month to rent, the math often favors renting.
You don't have a solid emergency fund. Homeownership comes with unpredictable expenses. A broken furnace ($5,000), roof damage ($8,000-$15,000), or plumbing emergency ($2,000-$5,000) can happen at any time. Without 3-6 months of expenses saved, one emergency could put you in serious financial trouble.
You value simplicity and flexibility. There's a real quality-of-life value in not worrying about maintenance, property values, or being tied to one location.
When Buying Wins
You're staying 5+ years in a stable market. Over time, you build equity (forced savings), potentially benefit from appreciation, and eventually pay off the mortgage entirely.
Your rent is comparable to a mortgage payment. If you're paying $2,000/month in rent and could buy a similar place for $2,200/month total, buying likely wins after a few years.
You want stability and control. No landlord can raise your rent, sell the building, or refuse to let you paint the walls. A fixed-rate mortgage means your housing cost is predictable for 30 years.
Tax benefits make sense for you. Mortgage interest and property tax deductions can be valuable — but only if you itemize deductions (which fewer people do since the standard deduction increased).
The Overlooked Option: Rent and Invest the Difference
If renting saves you $500/month compared to buying, investing that $500 at a 7% average return gives you $86,000 after 10 years. This is real wealth building — just not through homeownership.
The key is discipline. The "invest the difference" strategy only works if you actually invest the savings. If the extra money gets spent on lifestyle creep, buying forces the savings through mortgage payments.
Run Your Numbers
Your situation is unique. Use our rent vs buy calculator to compare the real costs based on your specific numbers — home price, rent, down payment, interest rate, and how long you plan to stay.
Rent vs Buy Calculator
Compare the real long-term costs of renting vs buying for your situation.
More Useful Tools
Mortgage Calculator
Calculate your monthly payment and total interest.
Calculate →Down Payment
Figure out how much you need to put down.
Calculate →Compound Interest
See what investing the difference could grow to.
Calculate →The Bottom Line
There's no universal right answer. Renting isn't throwing money away, and buying isn't always building wealth. Run the numbers for your specific situation, factor in your life plans, and make the decision that supports your overall financial goals — not just what people tell you you "should" do.